Beginner's Guide to AI Agents

AI agents don't just answer questions. They run tasks, trigger workflows, and work autonomously.

If you haven't started yet, this free guide covers everything: what they are, how they work, and how to set one up. Free when you subscribe to Mindstream.

Introduction

❝

Sometimes the honest answer to a renewal is one more year and a date to stop.

Luis R. Valentino, Ed.D.

In August, the U.S. Department of Education's Office of Elementary and Secondary Education sent districts a Dear Colleague letter on education technology. K-12 Dive reported that the letter suggested districts look for evidence of effectiveness and positive outcomes when they consider purchases and renewals, and build processes for reviewing how tools are implemented and what they do (Merod, 2026). That advice lands in a market where evidence is still thin. Instructure's 2026 Edtech Top 40 found that 52.5 percent of the 40 most-used tools carry at least Level IV evidence under the Every Student Succeeds Act (Instructure, 2026). Nearly half cannot claim even that. Meanwhile, the vendors already in the building start with an edge. In a survey of 200 district leaders, EdWeek Market Brief found that nearly nine in ten say incumbent vendors hold an advantage over newcomers, with track records and trust at the top of the list (EdWeek Market Brief, n.d.).

When a service contract comes up for renewal, a review should tell you how well it served the students, staff, or district it was meant for. In San Francisco, I faced that review with an intervention program. We looked at four things: how much the program was actually used, how easy it was to implement, the quality of its impact, and the long-term support and guidance the vendor provided. The gains were small. The review showed something else, too. Schedules and other resources had been built around the program, and shutting it down abruptly would have disrupted all of them. So I renewed it for one more year, knowing we would end it, and we told the vendor our decision.

Books by Luis R. Valentino, Ed.D.

Set the Measures Before You Sign

Our four questions worked in San Francisco because we could answer them. That means setting the measures before the first contract is signed, while the district can still insist on them. The National Association of State Procurement Officials describes a contract administration plan as a tool built in the pre-award stage, one that documents roles, pricing, performance measures, and payment terms (NASPO, n.d.). The same guidance treats monitoring performance as a key function of managing any contract, with usage reports and user feedback among the common tools (NASPO, n.d.).

Start with the problem. Before anyone pitches, your cabinet should be able to say in two or three sentences what is not working, for which students or staff, and how you will know in eighteen months whether it improved. Then ask every finalist for references from districts like yours, including one that stopped using the service. A provider confident in its work will give you that name.

Write the Renewal Into the First Contract

NASPO is direct on this point. Anticipated changes, including prices, time of performance, extensions, and renewals, belong in the contract's provisions from the beginning (NASPO, n.d.). Most service agreements describe what the provider will deliver. Fewer describe what the district will measure, when both parties will review results, or how the relationship ends.

Write those terms in. Name the outcomes the service is expected to move and the schedule for reporting on them. Spell out how the district gets its data back, in what format, and how quickly. Add the option of a final term at a defined scope, so a wind-down year is something the contract already allows instead of a favor you negotiate under pressure. Name the district's own obligations as well, because many implementations fail on your side of the table: the training days that never got scheduled, the coach reassigned in October, the data feed that broke and stayed broken.

Count the Whole Cost

The invoice shows only part of what a service costs. In guidance CoSN published on edtech purchasing, Frankie Jackson tells districts to account for everything, initial purchases and subscriptions, and both direct and indirect costs (Jackson, n.d.). For a service, the indirect costs are the ones nobody bills you for: staff time, training, and the schedules arranged around the work.

Those costs do not disappear when you cancel. They become the cost of leaving. That is why the program in San Francisco got one more year. An abrupt shutdown would have disrupted schedules and resources that had become part of the program, and a final year with a known end date was the responsible way out.

Renewal Has Three Answers

Renew when the measures you set at the start show the service is working. End it when they show it is not and little depends on it. Or renew once, with a date to stop and a plan for moving people and schedules onto whatever comes next.

The third answer depends on candor. Tell the vendor early, as we did, so the final year goes to an orderly transition. Then close the contract the way NASPO recommends, with a review of lessons learned, so the next purchase starts from what this one taught you (NASPO, n.d.).

Before winter break, list every service contract that renews by June 30. Next to each one, write the answer your evidence supports today (renew, end, or one more year) and the date your cabinet will decide. Where you cannot fill in the evidence, you have found the first item on your January agenda.

References

EdWeek Market Brief. (n.d.). Tracking why 'incumbent' K-12 companies hold a competitive edge over newcomers. https://marketbrief.edweek.org/exclusive-data/tracking-why-incumbent-k-12-companies-hold-a-competitive-edge-over-newcomers/

Instructure. (2026, June 29). New Instructure data shows K-12 districts are demanding evidence, not just access to edtech tools [Press release]. PR Newswire. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/new-instructure-data-shows-k-12-districts-are-demanding-evidence-not-just-access-to-edtech-tools-302812840.html

Jackson, F. (n.d.). Using value of investment (VOI) to guide edtech purchasing and sustainability planning decisions. CoSN. https://www.cosn.org/using-value-of-investment-voi-to-guide-edtech-purchasing-and-sustainability-planning-decisions/

Merod, A. (2026, August 20). Education Department goes to ed tech's defense in new guidance. K-12 Dive. https://www.k12dive.com/news/education-department-goes-to-ed-techs-defense-in-new-guidance/828425/

National Association of State Procurement Officials. (n.d.). Contract administration best practices. https://cdn.naspo.org/RI/Contract-Administration-Best-Practices-Guide.pdf

The Video Edition

Catch the weekly video edition of the EDL Newsletter on YouTube.

Let's Talk

Every service contract that renews by June 30 needs an answer and a decision date before winter break.

This Week

Ask your business office for every service contract that renews by June 30: intervention programs, coaching, tutoring, professional development, software and consulting. Next to each one, note the notice deadline, the last day you can cancel or change terms. That date can come months before the contract ends.

Then write one of three answers beside each contract: renew, end or one more year. Base it on what you know today about how much the service was used, how well it was implemented, what changed for the students or staff it was meant to serve, and how the provider supported you.

Where you cannot fill in the evidence, schedule the data review now, while there is time to act on what it shows.

For every “one more year,” list what depends on the service (the schedules, positions and data that would break if it stopped tomorrow) and pick the date you will tell the provider.

Bring the list to your cabinet before the break. Start with the contract nobody wants to discuss.

Please share in the comments. I will respond.

DISTRICT LEADER PODCAST

The Savvy School Buyer: Navigating K-12 Procurement Strategies

The best time to bring your purchasing team into a decision is before anyone signs. In this episode of Cooperatively Speaking, Allison Lambert of E&I talks with her colleague Sue Peters, Vice President of K-12 Engagement, about why buying for schools has grown more complex, with staffing shortages, cybersecurity and tight budgets all pressing at once. They make the case for involving procurement early, using cooperative contracts, and coordinating across departments so spending matches educational goals. You’ll also hear real success stories in managing supply chain disruptions and building supplier diversity programs. Listen alongside this week’s issue on service contracts.

EDUPRENEURS NETWORK • DEEP DIVE

Value-Based Procurement in Education: Moving Beyond the Lowest Bid

In February, I wrote on Edupreneurs Network about why the lowest bid can cost a district more than it saves. The essay counts the full cost of ownership, including staff time, coordination and the cost of replacing a provider that fails, and it offers reference questions that go past satisfaction ratings, such as whether a district would choose the same provider again knowing what it knows now. Read it alongside this week’s issue. The costs it counts at purchase are the same ones that become the cost of leaving at renewal.

From the Bookshelf - Thought Leadership

Thought Leadership in Education: A Comprehensive Exploration of Transformative Educational Ideas

Chapter 3: The Scholarship of Educational Thought Leadership

A vendor’s evidence comes from someone else’s district. In Chapter 3, I wrote that “effective thought leaders understand that evidence doesn’t travel well without context.” What succeeds in one school or district can falter in another because the students, communities, resources or culture differ. The chapter asks leaders to go beyond what works in general and ask for whom, in what setting and how it works. The section that follows goes further and asks what a body of evidence leaves out, and who. A renewal review is the first time those questions can have a local answer, because by then you hold a year or more of your own data.

This week: Read “Context Matters: Avoiding One-Size-Fits-All Conclusions” and “A Critical Eye on Evidence Gaps” in Chapter 3 (pages 48–51). Then ask yourself: which of the services I am about to renew have I judged by the vendor’s evidence instead of my own?

Additional Resources

Article

School Board Procurement Oversight in 2026 by the edCircuit editorial staff

edCircuit’s editors argue that procurement oversight has become a core governance duty for school boards. Trustees do not need to negotiate contracts, the piece says, but they should understand the risks built into them. It lists the questions to ask: how much future budget renewals already commit, which agreements carry automatic price escalators, what the exit timelines and data terms say, and whether anyone checked usage before a renewal reached the agenda. Share it with your board president before the spring renewal cycle.

Read more →
Guide

Orienting Towards Outcomes: Results-Driven Approaches to Contract Management by Elena Hoffnagle and Hope Patterson, Harvard Kennedy School Government Performance Lab

A renewal decision can only rest on evidence if the measures exist before the work starts. This free how-to guide shows public agencies how to shift contract management from compliance toward results. It recommends reviewing baseline data and key performance indicators at kickoff (two or three for a mid-level contract), holding regular performance meetings, and matching how closely you manage a contract to its risk, value and complexity. Its closeout steps include an end-of-contract performance report. Use it to build the measures into your next service agreement.

Explore →
Standard

Global Best Practice: Contract Closeout by NIGP

The cost of leaving shows up when a contract ends, but NIGP places the planning at the start. Its best-practice standard tells purchasing teams to begin closeout planning while they develop the solicitation, and to start closeout early enough to prepare a new one. It separates expected endings, such as expiration or a move to a new supplier, from termination for cause or convenience. For service and technology contracts, it covers returning data, removing the vendor’s access, and whether the outgoing contractor must train the incoming one. Read it before you sign, then write those terms into the contract.

Explore →

Daily news for curious minds.

Be the smartest person in the room. 1440 navigates 100+ sources to deliver a comprehensive, unbiased news roundup — politics, business, culture, and more — in a quick, 5-minute read. Completely free, completely factual.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate